North Anna: 继电保护设备太敏感导致断电
Automatic Disconnect From the Grid Didn't Need to Occur, Experts Say, Noting Safeguards Tailored for Western Temblors
By REBECCA SMITH
Nuclear experts likely will reassess the design of dozens of U.S. reactors in the wake of Tuesday's earthquake in Virginia that drew scrutiny when the plant temporarily lost electricity from the grid—the result of construction geared for the kind of temblor that hits Western parts of the U.S., not the East.
The finding is expected to put a spotlight on many plants east of the Rockies so they can better ride out Eastern-type quakes.
The North Anna station came through Tuesday's 5.8-magnitude temblor without apparent structural damage.
"Nothing loose, no dust, no cracks," said a relieved David Heacock, chief nuclear officer for the plant's owner, Dominion Resources Inc.
But what's now clear is that the central Virginia plant tripped out of service when there was no real need for that to happen.
Experts believe sensitive electrical equipment at North Anna responded to high-frequency ground motion—which is a hallmark of Eastern quakes, but not of Western ones—as if it were an electrical disturbance. Nine relays designed to protect expensive transformers from damage
misread that cue, temporarily cutting off the plant from the electric grid, according to Dominion's Mr. Heacock.
Every earthquake produces a broad range of ground motion frequencies, expressed in "hertz" or cycles per second. But Western quakes are more noted for the lower frequencies that are especially damaging to large, rigid structures, such as buildings and bridges. Higher frequencies are more debilitating to finely tuned equipment such as electrical or electronic devices.
So it's no surprise the impact was seen at North Anna's switchyard—the place where electrical-service lines enter the plant and where electricity made by the reactors is put back on the grid.
While diesel-fueled generators kicked in to supply power, the automatic shutdown still raised concerns. What ha's been learned since the earthquake— the worst to hit Virginia in more than a century—supports a belief by seismologists that East Coast quakes have special characteristics that need to be factored into construction of nuclear plants.
Shock waves in the East travel longer distances with tight waves—"like hitting a piece of steel with a hammer," says seismologist William Hinze, professor emeritus at Purdue University in Indiana. Western earthquakes are more like "hitting a piece of rubber," he says, with shock waves more quickly smothered. That helps explain why the Virginia quake was felt as far away as Canada.
One fix looks likely. Plant operators could change the orientation of relays so they aren't so easily fooled. That's harder than it sounds since engineers need to make sure they still can sense real danger. With the analysis still in its early stage, other changes may be required. The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission has a team at the site.
Tuesday's earthquake, centered about 10 miles from the North Anna plant, may have come at just the right time and in just the right place. The NRC already was in the midst of a multiyear effort to deepen its understanding of earthquake risks in the Central and Eastern U.S. and apply that knowledge to improving existing plants and new plants even better.
In fact, North Anna's two reactors already were on a list of 27 reactors that the NRC has concluded are in greatest need of additional seismic analysis. One reason is that additional faults have been identified since those reactors were built. North Anna has two reactors and a third one has been proposed.
"There's a lot of learning to be done and we will gather every bit of information we can from this earthquake," said Mr. Hinze, who is helping the NRC with its seismic update.
Dominion is still seeking information that will help it minutely depict the profile of this week's earthquake. After the reactors "scrammed"—meaning the nuclear reaction was stopped—they still had to cool down before inspectors could get inside the reactor-containment buildings.
Once the Unit 1 reactor was shut down, the utility sent in workers, wearing gloves, who carefully removed special "scatch plates" that record earthquake data. That process took eight hours. "We had guys up all night extracting them," said Mr. Heacock.
Dominion was so eager to get the plates analyzed that it flew the first batch "to California on a private jet," said Dominion's Mr. Heacock.
The plant remained shut down on Friday. Neither reactor is likely to restart soon, especially with Hurricane Irene approaching.
Write to Rebecca Smith at
rebecca.smith@wsj.com